익명 01:03

Does creating a parent reverse lookup zone delete or delegate existing independe...

Does creating a parent reverse lookup zone delete or delegate existing independently-created child zones?

We have an AD-integrated DNS environment with ~80 reverse lookup zones built up over years, all created independently with no parent zone. The 10.in-addr.arpa parent does not exist; we just have dozens of standalone x.10.in-addr.arpa zones, multiple x.172.in-addr.arpa zones, and a handful of others (100.192.10.in-addr.arpa, 168.192.in-addr.arpa, etc).

We want to create 10.in-addr.arpa as a consolidation point, then migrate the existing child zones into it one at a time and delete the old standalone zones as we go.

The core question: what does creating 10.in-addr.arpa do to the existing child zones that sit "under" it?

Specifically:

  1. Are existing child-zone records destroyed? The known TechNet behaviour is that creating a child zone under an existing parent can wipe records. Does the same happen in reverse, i.e. creating the parent after the children exist?
  2. Are auto-delegations created in the new parent pointing at the existing child zones, and how quickly?
  3. Do the child zones keep answering queries normally while the parent exists alongside them?
  4. Where does dynamic registration go for subnets with no existing child zone, once the parent exists?

DCs are a mix of Windows Server 2019 Standard (majority) and 2025 Standard. No lab/replica available to test, so I can't trial this against production blind. Documentation covering this specific "parent created after children" case would also be welcome, we've found plenty on the normal top-down order but nothing on this.



Top Answer/Comment:

Comment: I suspect that this will only require a few minutes to verify in your test environment, however I would be surprised if Windows DNS created "auto delegations" or if existing records would be destroyed, at least not without prompting for confirmation. It's probably worth noting that Windows and Active Directory don't use reverse lookup records for anything, that is mostly an artifact of code that was added for feature parity purposes. If this is a feature you actually need, I recommend creating a suitable "test environment".

상단 광고의 [X] 버튼을 누르면 내용이 보입니다